Former Yorktown Comptroller Asked to Return $77K to Town

Joan Goldberg, who filed a notice of petition on Oct. 9, had written a check for $76,959.63 to herself for accumulated unused vacation time. The town is asking for the money back.

Yorktown town board members are asking former town comptroller Joan Goldberg to return approximately $77,000 she wrote to herself in a check for accumulated unused vacation time. 

"We don't believe she is owed it," Yorktown Supervisor Michael Grace said. 

Grace said Goldberg, who served the town for the last 16 years and began a new job as the first-ever town administrator in North Castle last month, wrote the check for $76,959.63 on Sept. 11. He said Goldberg had accumulated 181.5 vacation days – at $424.05 per day, totalling $76,959.63.

Yorktown town board members discussed the issue in executive session on Sept. 26 and then voted in open session to pass a resolution authorizing town attorney Jeannette Koster to send a letter to Goldberg's attorney demanding she returns the money.

The vote was 4-1 with Councilman Nick Bianco voting against the resolution. 

"I'm comfortable with my 'No' vote," he said. "I pride myself to be fair and not capricious and arbitrary." 

Because of a notice of petition, which was filed by Goldberg's attorney on Oct. 9, Bianco refused to comment any further and disclose what the discussion entailed. (Check back with Patch on the filed notice of petition.)

Yorktown Councilman Dave Paganelli also refused to comment.

"It's a legal issue," he said. "I was advised not to comment."

Goldberg told Patch she filed the notice of petition after town board members passed the resolution on Sept. 26 characterizing her actions as "conversion of town funds."

"All I'm asking for is that they rescind that resolution and they rescind the finding that my actions were improper," Goldberg said.

She said she had a discussion with town board members on April 17 when she told them how much each town employee had in unused vacation time. The document contained data until the end of 2011 and at that time Goldberg had $72,506.60 in unused vacation time, she said. 

She stands by her actions and says she is owned the money – $76,959.63 before taxes and deductions, and $42,957.56 after taxes and deductions.

Earlier this year, based on a recommendation by Goldberg and an auditor, the town set up an employee benefit reserve fund, which had approximately $1 million in it, Grace said. He said Goldberg took the direct deposit for her unused vacation time out of that fund. 

"Having that fund set up provided her with a line to take out a direct deposit without coming to us," Grace said. 

Grace said in 1993, town board members at the time passed a resolution that created a policy stating that department heads had the same employee benefits as the members of the CSEA. In order for an employee or department head to roll over unused vacation time, the person needed approval from town board members first and no more than 35 days could be rolled over in total, he said.

"I did not make the rules," he said. "I inherited the rules. The rules were pretty clear."

Grace said there are two issues. One – Goldberg acted as an auditor of her own unused vacation time when she did the direct deposit and someone else should have been her auditor. Two – there were no resolutions by previous town boards allowing for any roll over of Goldberg's unused vacation time, Grace said. 

"I don't have anything on file," he said. "At this point, without any resolutions showing that she was allowed the roll over, then she is not entitled to it."

Grace said the town wants Goldberg, whom he said had the most amount of unused vacation time in town, to return the money. 

"No one is begrudging her to it if she is entitled, but she is not entitled to it," he said. 

Goldberg; however, said that policy, which was implemented before she was hired in 1996, did not set forth a procedure for the accumulation of vacation time. 

"Not one department head in 20 years has had a resolution passed authorizing the carry over of vacation," said Goldberg, naming one other former employee who cashed in $10,000 per year for eight years prior to retirement. "Why am I being treated differently?"

Let Patch save you time. Get great local stories delivered right to your inbox or smartphone everyday with our free newsletter. Simple, fast sign-up here.

Like us on Facebook | Follow us on Twitter | Sign up for our newsletter

Sami October 11, 2012 at 04:49 PM
If there was nothing wrong with it, why didnt she have someone clearly approve the check or actually write it? It looks very sneaky that she wrote this check to herself- which I still dont understand. Where is the accountability?! I know in my company the person who cuts the check cannot be the same person who signs the check AND any checks over $10,000 must be signed by two people. The lack of oversight is scary. It isnt anyones fault that she didnt take any vacation days in 16 years (which I personally find hard to believe), but I have never heard of getting reimbursed for vacation days you didnt use when you leave the position. Carrying over a certain amount to use- fine up to a limit- but its almost like being double paid. The company (town in this case) expects to pay you for every day that year- but if you take no vacation days, you get paid for that day in your regular pay check and then are taking additional pay for that day- so you are being paid twice for those days. Doesnt sound right and she should have to return the money.
Jay Horgan October 11, 2012 at 06:56 PM
If the ex comptroller felt that this in fact was duely owed to her, there should have been no reason for her to write her own check. She could have gone to the Town Board, or Supervisor and requested the Town to approve the payment. After this payment request was properly reviewed, It then should be approved by someone of authority, other than herself If everything was in order and her unused vacation days were reviewed and confirmed, this scenario would never have taken place. This payment seems inapproriate to say the least, How can a Comptroller write their own check, It simply does not sit well with me.
The Real Yorktown Town Hall October 12, 2012 at 12:28 AM
The comptroller wrote her own paycheck for 16 years. Town hall was put on notice that there is no policy that forbids department heads from rolling over sick and vacation time. A fund was set up to cover that liability (it's not just Joan Goldberg Yorktown owes such accrued time). This is a personal vendetta. Town hall will spend at least $140,000 to try and claw back the $70,000 plus she was owed. We're in agreement that the roll-over policy is bad fiscal policy. Why doesn't the town board pass a resolution declaring the practice over and vacate or grandfather the exact same vacation and sick pay owed to other officials? Good question. Why did they approve a 1 million dollar reserve to cover this very real liability? Good question.
Francis T McVetty October 14, 2012 at 05:27 PM
From reading all this I have concluded that we need to look very carefully at the procedures that brought us to this point. Some thing is wrong when someone can accumulate 16 years of "lost' vacation time. How many others are there now working for the town accumulating lost vacation time?
Francis T McVetty October 14, 2012 at 05:30 PM
@The Real Yorktown Town Hall, It should NOT cost $140,000 to resolve the issue. In fact we do have a FULL time lawyer on premises, don't we? Have her lawyer call our lawyer and work out something.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »